Death Wish ★★★★★

deathwish (Custom)This review is written with a GPL 4.0 license and the rights contained therein shall supersede all TOS by any and all websites in regards to copying and sharing without proper authorization and permissions. Crossposted at WordPress, Blogspot & Librarything by Bookstooge’s Exalted Permission
Title: Death Wish
Series: ———-
Author: Brian Garfield
Rating: 5 of 5 Stars
Genre: Psychological Fiction
Pages: 192
Format: Digital Edition


Paul Benjamin is a successful accountant in New York City. One afternoon his wife and married daughter are attacked in Paul’s apartment and savagely beaten. His wife dies and his daughter ends up in a sanitarium, insane for all intents and purposes.

Paul has always been a good guy. He’s done charity work for prison reform, contributes to causes left and right and thinks that if he obeys the rules that Society will protect him. With the attack on his family this delusion is ripped away and Paul must confront what living in a big city really means.

As he mulls these thoughts over, he begins to change. He realizes he has been afraid and he is now going to stop being afraid. But how does one stop being afraid? By taking responsibility for ones self is the conclusion Paul comes to.

On a business trip to the Mid-West Paul has a one night stand with some stranger at his hotel. When she leaves he realizes how empty his life is. How empty those hoodlums have made his life. He buys a small calibre pistol at a fishing shop and takes it back to New York with him hidden in his carry on baggage.

Paul begins roaming the city at night, exposing himself to danger so as to kill the perpetrators of violence and crime. After several kills the papers pick up on the fact that there is a vigilante on the loose. The book ends with Paul having just shot 4 teenagers who were throwing 50lb rocks onto a train to kill people inside and a cop seeing him. The cop raises his hat and deliberately turns his back and Paul walks home.

My Thoughts:

My goodness, another fantastic book for this year. Definitely gets the “Best Book of the Year” tag.

So, this review might be long and rambly, please bear with me or just skip it. Either way, it’s all good.

I had heard about this through the 1974 film starring Charles Bronson. Knowing the type of movie Bronson usually starred in, I never got around to watching it. Then in 2018 a remake with Bruce Willis was made and it eventually came to Amazon Prime. I watched the reboot, as I really like Willis. That led me to watching the original with Bronson and then to hunting down the book. I plan on talking about the movies in a Versus post later this month. Death Wish vs Death Wish vs Death Wish!

Based on the synopsis and the movies, I was expecting a book about a vigilante getting his revenge. A soft, pasty, weakminded fool seeing reality for the first time in his life and going all gung-ho to the other extreme. What I got was a psychological book that impressed me over and over and over. Paul never finds the hoodlums who killed his wife and he never expects to. What I read was the mind of a man pushed beyond its self-imposed limits. It wasn’t pretty, it wasn’t always easy to read about but it was good.

I’ve always considered Crime & Punishment to be THE book on what a criminal mind goes through after a murder. Death Wish is entering the same territory in my mind but from the other end. What does a man go through when he truly realizes how broken, destructive and unsafe his world is? This book shows the answer to that.

Given the fact that I already agree with most of the statements made in this book (see my Quote post from the other day) it is no surprise that I liked this. The only part I struggled with was Paul taking the role of Executioner into his own hands, not lightly, but so determinedly. I believe that every human has the God given right to defend themselves. I believe that laws like the Stand Your Ground laws are essential to a free society. However, when defense of Self moves into the defense of Society then I cannot blindly accept or promote it. But neither do I blindly negate it. Evil, and people who commit acts of Evil ARE evil, must be resisted not only by the dutifully elected officials of Law and Order but by every conscientious citizen as well. The flip side of the Right to Self-defense is the Responsibility of Self-defense. This book was written in 1972 and is pretty dated but the battle that Paul goes through in his mind is as relevant today as it was then.

I don’t know what someone who is in staunch opposition to the right of self-defense would make of this book. I don’t think it would change their mind. It is not meant to however. This was a book written to all of those people who sit on the fence and think they are safe because “of the police” or that “it couldn’t happen here in Safe Safe Happy Funland.” Brian Garfield also NEVER ridicules those who think like Paul at the beginning of the book. I really appreciated that.

I would love to unreservedly recommend this book but honestly, I can’t. For me, it was the right book at the right time. People can have their minds changed and responsibility can grow from even the stinkiest compost heap.

To end, this was not an action/adventure novel of revenge and over the top violence. This was the story of a man finally growing up.


bookstooge (Custom)

20 thoughts on “Death Wish ★★★★★

  1. Sounds like a really impactful read for you. I only read about that book, mind you, but I read that it’s much more nuanced than the movie (I only watched Bronson’s one, can’t seem to stand remakes anymore ;))

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I’m going to be doing a post in a saturday or two (probably 2) contrasting the 2 movies and the book. Needless to say, you are correct in your surmise about the book being nuanced. The Bronson movie kind of aims for that and goes low and the reboot (which I liked a lot) just goes straight for the shoes. It doesn’t even try 😀

      Liked by 1 person

    1. Definitely no easy answers. And Garfield (the author, not the cat!) doesn’t even touch on any aspect of religion. That opens up the horizon even wider.

      Glad to share. Definitely helped me bolster my mind in the midst of killing myself with manga 😀

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Max Pain has an early 80’s feel to it. Thats the charm of it all for me. Guy (cop) comes home to find his wife and child murdered, mafia is involved so he goes after them all alone. One of my all time favorites…

        Liked by 1 person

  2. The first thought I had was that it reminded me of Crime and Punishment as well. I’m glad to hear that it takes a look inside the mind of a man whose going through important changes in his perception of life and death/good and evil. I’m definitely tempted in checking this out now. I’ll maybe even try the original movie first too, or wait on your review of it first. Excellent stuff, glad you enjoyed it.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I liked the book the most between all 3 versions.
      But honestly, since I KNOW you’re not going to rush out and buy the book and read it this week, wait until next weekend to see what you think of the movies. Of course, I think the Death Wish movies (reboot and original) are free on Prime right now…

      Liked by 1 person

  3. Wow this sounds like it deals with some important concepts really well (tbh I don’t know what would change the mind of someone who is against self-defence and I’ve encountered a few people like that). Glad this was the right book for you and it does sound worth checking out 🙂

    Liked by 2 people

    1. Dang mouse, I hope you don’t get notified 6 times of me liking your comment. It kept double clicking for some reason.

      Anyway, yeah, I really doubt this would change a hardcore’s mind. But for it would at least give some mental fodder to any one who hasn’t thought about it before.

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s