Kingfisher ★★★★½

813bb0ae2cd9d5bf7e732d08597f0bd9This review is written with a GPL 4.0 license and the rights contained therein shall supersede all TOS by any and all websites in regards to copying and sharing without proper authorization and permissions. Crossposted at WordPress, Blogspot & Librarything by Bookstooge’s Exalted Permission
Title: Kingfisher
Series: ———-
Author: Patricia McKillip
Rating: 4.5 of 5 Stars
Genre: Fantasy
Pages: 302
Words: 87K



From & authored by Alyx Dellamonica

Pierce Oliver lives in a world that fuses our high-tech present day with the top-down political structure of a high fantasy medieval kingdom. It’s the kind of place where limousine-riding kings preside over jousts, where the court magicians argue over the academic citations and feminist interpretations of their ancient texts, and where the bastard princes are doing well if they manage to stay out of the tabloids. The country’s biggest ongoing problem is keeping its surplus of troublesome knights from taking it into their heads to overthrow the government.

When Pierce is a young man this hardly matters, because he lives in a small town far removed from the capital, a backwater whose existence is known to but a few. His home is in fact concealed by magic, an enchantment wielded by Pierce’s somewhat clingy mother, Heloise, a retired witch living incognito as a slow foods restaurateur. One day three knights stumble through town by accident, and by the time they’ve moved on, Pierce has decided to strike out on his own, seeking information on the father he never knew and–perhaps as importantly–cutting the apron strings that have bound him so tightly to his mother’s chosen refuge.

Packing up his car and charging his cell phone, Pierce heads down the road and almost immediately stumbles into–rather surprisingly–another restaurant, this one in a dilapidated hotel called the Kingfisher, a place that has fallen on hard times. There he encounters Carrie, a hard-working chef who also dreams of escaping her particular Nowheresville of a community. Pierce partakes of a peculiarly ritualistic fish fry there, before spending the night in one of their rooms. On his way out the door, he gives in to an irresistible not-quite-whim to filch a cooking knife from the place.

The theft, of course, is less a failure of moral fiber than a magical imperative, and by the time Pierce makes it to the capital, the effects of his minor act of banditry are reverberating throughout the land. The King has decided to declare a nationwide quest for… well, definitely for something. A grail? A relic? A fountain of youth? Whatever the Object in question is, his upstart knights will surely know it when they see it. In the meantime, if their motoring forth and scouring the kingdom keeps them from getting up to revolutionary scale trouble, so much the better.

The problem with this scheme is it isn’t entirely a PR scam. The quest Object is real enough, and the mere idea of seeking it sets off a feud between two major religions, a fight that breaks down more or less on gender lines: there’s a cult with masculine, metal-dominated values and a male god, and a watery, priestess-led faith centered in the ladies’ birthing chamber. Both sides are absolutely, positively sure that the quest’s Object belongs to their patron deity. And for at least some of the men and women on the hunt, this ambiguity is awesome, simply because it means they have a license to stampede around the whole countryside, kicking over lesser shrines, sifting through their relics, and beating on anyone who might object.

Carrie and Pierce have other problems too, in the form of a third restaurant owner, a slippery figure called Stillwater who is almost certainly in the know about whatever it is that has blighted the Kingfisher Inn. Now he has his sights set on Carrie herself, and is tempting her with job offers she definitely ought to refuse.

Publishers Blurb & Me

Hidden away from the world by his mother, the powerful sorceress Heloise Oliver, Pierce has grown up working in her restaurant in Desolation Point. One day, unexpectedly, strangers pass through town on the way to the legendary capital city. “Look for us,” they tell Pierce, “if you come to Severluna. You might find a place for yourself in King Arden’s court.”

Lured by a future far away from the bleak northern coast, Pierce makes his choice. Heloise, bereft and furious, tells her son the truth: about his father, a knight in King Arden’s court; about an older brother he never knew existed; about his father’s destructive love for King Arden’s queen, and Heloise’s decision to raise her younger son alone.

As Pierce journeys to Severluna, his path twists and turns through other lives and mysteries: an inn where ancient rites are celebrated, though no one will speak of them; a legendary local chef whose delicacies leave diners slowly withering from hunger; his mysterious wife, who steals Pierce’s heart; a young woman whose need to escape is even greater than Pierce’s; and finally, in Severluna, King Arden’s youngest son, who is urged by strange and lovely forces to sacrifice his father’s kingdom.

Things are changing in that kingdom. Oldmagic is on the rise. The immensely powerful artifact of an ancient god has come to light, and the king is gathering his knights to quest for this profound mystery, which may restore the kingdom to its former glory—or destroy it.

In the end, Stillwater is recaptured by the women of Ravenshold, Prince Damion brings peace between Ravenshold and Wyvernshold, the magic is brought back in balance to the Kingfisher and the Holy Grail is revealed to be a magic cooking pot used at the Kingfisher.

My Thoughts:

The reason this still only gets 4.5stars instead of 5 is because of the cover. I’m sorry, but Kinuko Craft covers are the physical embodiment of the stories that McKillip tells. This bland, no-nothing cover is a blot. Now, that is the fault of the publishers, so I don’t blame McKillip one iota but it still plays a part. Penguin, and their imprint Ace, should be heartily ashamed of themselves. In fact, I would gladly volunteer to help them commit seppuku for this disastrous, face shaming act they committed against this great book.

Now, there are some differences from her previous books. This takes place in “modern” times even while magic is in existence. There is also a much larger cast of characters. There are also several concurrent storylines instead of just the one or two. These various differences, while not bad, definitely contributed towards this feeling like a highly embroidered neckerchief instead of a wall scroll with one central picture. Smaller in scope but more “things” going on to keep one occupied.

I was thinking this was the last McKillip I had on my re-read journey and was pretty sad about that. It was coloring this whole read until about half-way through I realized I still had a collection of short stories to go through entitled Harrowing the Dragon. Then the sun came out, the birds began chirping and cherries fell directly into my mouth, already pitted. Life was wonderful again 😀



bookstooge (Custom)


43 thoughts on “Kingfisher ★★★★½

  1. This sounds really good. Are there other covers for other editions? Personally, I like this one but get what you’re saying too. It’s funny because a lot of times I end up loving the Kindle version covers and wish they’d used those for the physical. ☺️ Have a good week!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. There are not other covers for this specific book. Her previous books were all done by an artist named Kinuko Craft and they collaborated for years. It was sad to not see another Craft cover.


  2. The sun and birds sound good, but I’m a little skeptical of the cherries. First of all, I’d be afraid of choking and think somebody was trying to kill me. Second of all, who pitted them and did they wash their hands first? Also, I hope they were fresh cherries and not those nasty candied cherries! 😉

    Liked by 2 people

      1. Haha, riiiight! 😉

        Candied cherries are the nasty, fake-tasting, sweet-yet-somehow-terrible cherries that you might find lurking on top of an ice cream sundae to make everything taste bad. I think that’s what they’re called, anyway. This is different than the yummy sweet, syrupy cherry filling that goes in a cherry pie. At least, they taste completely different to me, but I don’t actually know how any of it is made. And neither of them taste anything like fresh cherries to me, which I also like.

        Liked by 2 people

                  1. LOL, there must be a few others out there who feel the same or I wouldn’t have to dig them out of my ice cream so often, along with the unfortunately contaminated ice cream that was touching it.

                    Liked by 2 people

                    1. Don’t worry, I hate them too! 😀 It’s like they’ve been put into sugary formalin and became specimens on some mad scientist’s shelf.

                      Liked by 2 people

                    2. LOL, I love your description of them, and I’m relieved to find some sanity in this crazy corner of the internet! 😉

                      Liked by 1 person

  3. That cover is truly horrid. Even though I still have to read a McKillip that I actually adore as much as you do, this doesn’t seem to do justice to her poetic style and whimsical mood… Looks rather like something that could adorn Twilight novels 😛

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Yes, it is the quintessential ya girly cover as far as I’m concerned. I think it was deliberate on the publishers to try to break McKillip into the ya audience and sell to that gaping vacuum. The more fools they….

      Liked by 1 person

  4. “I was thinking this was the last McKillip I had on my re-read journey and was pretty sad about that. It was coloring this whole read…”

    Hate when your mind plays games with you like that, even when you know it’s happening, you can’t stop it

    Liked by 1 person

  5. Oh, just stop it! You keep posting McKillup books and she is DEFINITELY an author I want to try but my library has none of her books and I’m on a book-buying-halt for the next little while anyway. So I want, but can’t have. At least I know I have something to look forward to, huh? Keep posting those reviews!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Sadly, I only have one more to go and then it will be a decade hiatus until the next re-read cycle 😦

      Good luck with the book buying halt. Probably good for you though…


    1. Personally, while I liked it, it was because it was a bit different than her medieval, fairy-tale stuff. I wouldn’t want her to write modern magic all the time, that is for sure.

      Liked by 2 people

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s