Kingdom Come ★☆☆☆☆

This review is written with a GPL 4.0 license and the rights contained therein shall supersede all TOS by any and all websites in regards to copying and sharing without proper authorization and permissions. Crossposted at WordPress, Blogspot & Librarything by Bookstooge’s Exalted Permission
Title: Kingdom Come
Series: Elseworlds
Author: Mark Wade
Artist: Alex Ross
Rating: 1 of 5 Stars
Genre: Graphic Novel
Pages: 232
Words: 23K


From Wikipedia

In this Elseworlds story, Superman and the Justice League abandon their roles as superheroes after the rise and strong public support of a superhero named Magog, who has no qualms about killing—notably the Joker, on his way to trial for the mass murder of the Daily Planet staff, including Lois Lane. In the ensuing years, a newer generation of superpowered metahumans arise; they engage each other in destructive battles with little distinction between “heroes” and “villains.” The narrator, a minister named Norman McCay, receives apocalyptic visions of the future from a dying Wesley Dodds. The Spectre appears to McCay and recruits him to help pass judgment on the approaching superhuman apocalypse.

An attack on the Parasite, led by Magog, goes awry when Parasite tears open Captain Atom. As a result, much of the American Midwest is irradiated, killing millions and destroying a large portion of the United States’s food production. Coaxed back into action by Wonder Woman, Superman returns to Metropolis and re-forms the Justice League.

He recruits new heroes along with older ones. The most prominent exception is the Batman, who resents Superman for leaving the world 10 years ago. Batman warns Superman that his idealist notions are outdated and his interference will only exacerbate the world’s problems, insisting that strategy is required, not force. In response to Superman’s Justice League, Batman activates his network of agents called the “Outsiders”, made up largely of the younger second and third-generation heroes, while trusted veterans, such as Green Arrow and Blue Beetle, are chosen as lieutenants. Lex Luthor has organized the “Mankind Liberation Front”. The MLF is secretly a group of Golden Age villains, including Catwoman, the Riddler, and Vandal Savage, as well as third-generation villains like Ra’s al Ghul’s successor, Ibn al Xu’ffasch, who is Bruce Wayne and Talia al Ghul’s son. The MLF works to take control of the world from the heroes.

Superman’s Justice League gathers more captives than converts, and his prison (nicknamed “the Gulag”) is filled to capacity almost as soon as it is built. Superman works to persuade the inmates that their methods are wrong-headed and dangerous, but his entreaties fall upon deaf ears. With hostile heroes and villains locked up together, pressure builds. Meanwhile, Superman learns that Wonder Woman’s ardent militant stance may be influenced by her recent exile from Paradise Island: in the eyes of the Amazons, her mission to bring peace to the outside world has failed, and she has thus been stripped of her royalty. Batman and his Outsiders seem to enter into an alliance with the MLF as a united front against the Justice League. Luthor plans to exacerbate the conflict between the League and the inmates of the Gulag; the ensuing chaos will afford Luthor an opportunity to seize power. Batman uses the Martian Manhunter to discover that an adult Billy Batson is under Luthor’s control. Batson, as Captain Marvel, is the only metahuman capable of matching Superman’s power. When the Gulag’s inmates riot and kill Captain Comet, Luthor unwittingly reveals to Batman he intends to use the brainwashed Batson to break open the Gulag. Batman’s forces ambush Luthor and his conspirators, but they are unable to restrain Batson, who transforms into Marvel and flies off. While Wonder Woman leads the Justice League to the superhuman prison riot, Superman confronts Batman. Batman tries to justify inaction, saying the world would be better off if all the metahumans destroyed each other. Superman points out that if all human life is sacred, then logically that includes superhuman life. Superman knows that Batman will act, because his entire crimefighting life is based upon the desire to prevent the loss of human life.

Moved by Superman’s sentiments, Batman tells Superman that Captain Marvel is under Luthor’s control and is on the way to the Gulag. Superman races to the Gulag, but upon arrival is struck down by Captain Marvel. The Gulag is breached, freeing the population, and inciting war between Wonder Woman’s Justice League and the metahuman prisoners. The Spectre and Norman look on as Wonder Woman’s League engages with the prisoners and Superman is kept at bay by Captain Marvel. Batman’s army arrives on site as an intervening third party. Batman is unable to stop Wonder Woman from killing the supervillain Von Bach, which increases the fury of the riot.

As conditions worsen, United Nations Secretary General Wyrmwood authorizes the deployment of three tactical nuclear warheads, hardened against metahuman powers. In the middle of their fight, Batman and Wonder Woman see the incoming stealth bombers piloted by the Blackhawk Squadron. They break off fighting and manage to stop two bombs, but miss the third. Captain Marvel uses his magic lightning bolt as a weapon against Superman. Superman manages to grab Marvel and allow the bolt to transform him into Billy. Holding Batson’s mouth shut, Superman tells him he is going to stop the remaining bomb, and Batson must make a choice: either stop Superman and allow the warhead to kill all the metahumans, or let Superman stop the bomb and allow the metahumans’ war to engulf the world. Superman tells Batson he must be the one to make this decision, as he is the only one who lives in both worlds: a man (as Batson) and a god (as Marvel). Batson, his mind now clear of Luthor’s influence, turns back into Captain Marvel. He flings Superman to the ground and flies after the missile. Marvel intercepts the missile and shouts “Shazam!” three times in rapid succession, detonating the bomb prematurely, and killing Batson in the process.

Despite Marvel’s sacrifice, most of the metahumans are obliterated in the explosion. Superman is unharmed, but does not realize that there are any other survivors. Enraged at the tremendous loss of life, Superman flies to the U.N. Building and threatens to bring it down atop the delegates as punishment for the massacre. The surviving metahumans arrive, but McCay is the one who talks him down, pointing out how his appearance and behavior are exactly the sort of reasons that normal humans fear the superpowered. Superman immediately ceases his rampage. He is handed Captain Marvel’s cape, and tells the U.N. that he will use his wisdom to guide, rather than lead, humankind. Superman ties Captain Marvel’s cape to a flagpole and raises it among the flags of the member nations of the U.N., suggesting that this role of guidance will be more political and global in nature than the classic crime-busting vigilantism of the past.[6] In the epilogue, the heroes strive to become fully integrated members of the communities. Wonder Woman’s exile from Paradise Island ends, and she becomes an ambassador for super-humanity, taking the survivors of the Gulag to Paradise Island for rehabilitation. Batman abandons his crusade and becomes a healer, rebuilding his mansion as a hospital to care for those wounded by the destruction of the Gulag. He reconciles with both Dick Grayson/Red Robin and his son, Ibn al Xu’ffasch. Superman begins the task of restoring the Midwestern farmlands devastated in Magog’s attempt to capture the Parasite. He comes to terms with his past as Clark Kent by accepting a pair of glasses from Wonder Woman, and shares a kiss with her before she returns to Paradise Island. Norman McCay resumes pastorship of his congregation, preaching a message of hope for humanity. Among the congregation is Jim Corrigan, the Spectre’s human host.

My Thoughts:

Where do I start? I liked the idea and the presentation.

But the damnably perverted and shallow philosophy absolutely killed this for me. I knew this wasn’t going to go well right from the introduction by Elliot Maggin when he starts talking about us all being modern gods and how he takes inspiration from Gandhi saying he would be a Hindu, Muslim, Jew, Christian or Buddhist, the idea being that he would do anything to advance his generic ideals even to the profanation of the very religions he’s claiming to want to represent.

Then we get the main narrator, a Christian pastor. Unfortunately, this “pastor” is of the God is just a name and simply represents a higher power to help us become better” variety. He’s not a Christian, he’s a Unitarian. Not once was the name of Christ mentioned. Even during the many, many, MANY out of context quotes from the book of Revelation (which by the way is the Revelation of Jesus Christ) God as a Force was what was shoved down the readers’ throats. I am finding that the older I get, the less patience I have for misrepresentations of Christianity. I’m not talking about differences of opinion of a hard to interpret Scripture, but blatant misuses of Scripture to forward a storyline while claiming TO represent Christianity. Sadly, most of these misrepresentations come from real life people doing the misrepresentation. Can anyone say Jim Bakker or Joel Osteen?

Next, you have Superman, Batman and Wonderwoman. All are portrayed as having been broken by the events of a new world. One thing that really stuck out was the various stances shown on superheroes taking lives. Superman and Batman are known for their stance on not taking lives. It is one of the defining characteristics of who they are. The authors here use that and the new heroes willingness to take lives at the drop of a hat. Unfortunately, killing, for any reason, even by the lawful authorities is show as something evil. One of the villains, Magog, killed the Joker in the past and that is portrayed on the same level as him killing Captain Atom and pretty much nuking the American midwest and killing MILLIONS of people. Things are just not that simplistic and I HATE when something serious is portrayed so unreasonably. This got into Message Territory instead of good story telling.

Then the ending. Everyone pretty much just agrees to get along. Pollyana much? I mean, the whole freaking story wouldn’t have happened if the characters had acted in the beginning like they did at the end. But there was no real mechanism to propel their changes.

Everything, from beginning to end, got my goat. This was an Elseworlds story that could have been great, could have been fantastic but completely failed in its execution and was completely bogged down by Message Politics.

You know what is really funny though? I read a review of this on another site where the person went off the rails because they were convinced this was all right wing politics, because it featured a “Christian” main character, had Superman, Batman and Wonderwomen as the good guys. They also claimed it was pro-gun, pro-life and pro-death sentence. Oh, oh, they also stated that from this they figured Wade was a Republican and thus this was a complete piece of garbage. Isn’t that awesome? I have no idea how they came to the conclusions they did but it made me do a little happy dance inside. Call me sick, but seeing someone else being miserable just made my day.

Just so you can get an alternate take, ie, a more positive one, feel free to visit’s Lashaan Review.


39 thoughts on “Kingdom Come ★☆☆☆☆

    1. As sad as it is, seeing that review actually made me enjoy my own misery. Almost as if I said to myself “Bookstooge, at least you didn’t dislike it as much as that Poor Sod”.

      I get that there are times that comics are pretty preachy. But then there are the times that that takes precedent over the story itself and that is just never good 😦


  1. I bought this a few years back based on the glowing reviews but didn’t enjoy the story. Without over-analyzing it, I just thought the story sucked. It was trying too hard to be so much more than what it actually was. I found it dull and depressing and couldn’t get what all the fuss was about. But this is “a classic” they cried!

    Oh well. It must be me, I thought. Until I read your review. You make some very good points and have managed a much deeper reading than I did. I was looking for an entertaining super hero story but it left me disappointed. I wasn’t looking for “Message Politics” but as you point out, this book is filled with them. And one last thing, I know Alex Ross is a hugely talented artist but I’ve never “got” his style. His figures always look and feel lifeless, wooden, and dull. Sorry Alex. Rant over! Cue the angry mob bearing pitchforks and torches!

    Liked by 2 people

    1. Having come out in the 90’s, I can see whythis was popular. It was one of the first steps into deconstructing the Super Hero mythology. (Watchmen is THE first step in my opinion). People love to destroy things that are good, that’s just a fact.

      I think my “deeper” reading is because I’m older. If I had read this back then, I still would have hated it, but that would have been about the extent of it. Sometimes getting older is a really good thing 😀

      I’ve never been a fan of the realistic look for comics. I was introduced to it with Vallejo’s Marvel Masterpieces cards and this book seemed very similar.

      Liked by 2 people

      1. I much prefer Watchmen, The Dark Knight Returns, and even Grant Morrison’s runs on Animal Man and Doom Patrol for deconstructing the super hero mythology. I missed Kingdom Come when it was released in 1996, so missed all the hype at the time. I also read it “old” and I remember that it took me a while to finish it. I tried rereading it recently but gave up halfway through.

        Ooh, you’ve piqued my interest name-dropping Vallejo. Is that the same Boris Vallejo who is famous for his paintings of sword and sorcery heroes accompanied by scantily-clad companions?..

        Liked by 1 person

        1. I didn’t like Watchmen either, no surprise 😀 I liked the idea of the Dark Knight Returns, just not the treatment of Superman in it. I’ve since learned that Miller isn’t a big Superman fan, but I walked into it blind at the time 😦

          Yep, the same Vallejo. And “scantiy clad” is being rather generous imo. Pornographic is what I call it. Thankfully, the masterpiece cards were intended for a younger audience so he had to scale back in that regards. I still have them in a binder today and they’re probably worth about the cardboard they are printed on 😀

          Liked by 1 person

          1. I’ve heard that about Frank Miller. Have you read his Superman Year One? I have the first issue but haven’t read it yet. Heard it was very average. I picked it up in a digital sale recently.

            You didn’t like Watchmen, eh? Oh well, nobody’s perfect!😉 Least of all Alan Moore.

            Liked by 1 person

            1. Once I realized Miller had it in for Superman, I’ve tried to avoid any of his stuff that deals with Supes even tangentially. Superman is my hero, even now 😀

              re: Watchmen

              Liked by 1 person

  2. All of us? Modern Gods? well, there goes hopes for humanity in the fucking dustbin then! *shrugs* xD

    ”Pollyana much?” Lol! xD

    I find now that Lashaan’s and your comic books reviews ARE IT! Everyone else can just stop writing reviews now! xD Seriously though, I loved reading this post despite your hatred for the book!

    Liked by 2 people

    1. Thanks Rain. I tend to have a very opposite reaction to a lot of comics than Lashaan has, but quite honestly, that makes it so much fun 🙂

      However, I don’t read/review enough graphic novels on a regular basis for you to abandon some of those other reviewers 😉

      the thing is, I actually agree with the philosophy behind the “humanity in the dustbin”. As a Christian we know that all of humanity is broken and hence whatever actions they take will eventually lead to something bad. But Superheroes have always been Christ archetypes for me, ie, somebody to save us. so books like this would be like me reading the Bible and saying “Nah, Jesus was just a man, not the Son of God”.

      Thanks for the recent follow too 🙂

      Liked by 2 people

      1. You know I was actually sure that I was following you already! I don’t know how I missed it though. Well, I have corrected it now. 🙂

        Yes DEFINITELY! Opposing thoughts on books make for great discussions! 😉

        Hmm…you are right about that. Changing the very foundation of a superhero’s character suddenly is definitely not going to sit well with the readers.

        Liked by 1 person

        1. Did you perchance take a long hiatus anytime in the last year? I regularly go through my followers list and clean out the inactive people. You easily could have been swept up in something like that. Other than that, I have no idea.

          Liked by 1 person

            1. Ahhhh, that would be why then.
              It is unusual for a blogger to come back from a hiatus, in my experience, and so I tend to treat it like a going away. And sometimes I’m wrong 😀

              Liked by 1 person

  3. I should’ve guessed this reaction from the start. Or maybe I just subconsciously wanted to see it put into words by the Great Bookstooge. 😉 I have to say that the whole exclusion of Jesus Christ from the narrative while still using elements of Christianity worked better for me since it allowed to reduce the religion itself to something more “theoretical” with common conceptions of it serving as the foundation of the religion. I can definitely understand why it bothered you that it sort of “disrespected” the religion though.

    I also saw the Magog and Captain Atom events as tackling two different ideas, the first one is when the justice system decided to give a pass to a “hero” who decided to “kill” and that society decided to “accept” it. The second it the matter of collateral damage and the chaos before the devastating destruction of Captain Atom’s death which just knocked Superman out in his purpose and ability to save people and not be at the heart of it all. I then saw Superman’s decision to exit his role as a hero as his loss of hope in humanity and himself. Which then made his tyrannical return, influenced by Wonder Woman, as a path that seemed so interesting to explore. That Pollyana comment was funny though. It was nice that Shazam was the key to everyone realizing if there was any hope left in humanity too.

    Greatly appreciate the shout-out too. I don’t know how much you regret having read this now though but at least you now have another huge DC classic under your belt! 😀 Did you already own this before I reviewed it or did you pick it up afterward? Do you now plan on giving that Ross-less sequel a try? 😛 Does this review also mean that you haven’t given up on graphic novels yet? :O :O :O Although a 1-star review is probably the last thing to ever motivate you into continuing with the medium hahahah

    Liked by 2 people

    1. I don’t regret reading this at all. Any sting I felt was washed away when I read that other person’s review because it made me laugh so much 😀

      Surprisingly, I AM going to The Kingdom. I’d like to say it can’t be any worse than this, but then I’d be asking for Murphy to prove me wrong 😀

      I suspect my graphic novel days will be reading ones that I see reviewed by other people that peak my interest. I don’t plan on just browsing randomly.

      Liked by 2 people

  4. Great review!

    I thought, reading the summary, that it sounded quite political. It did sound like it was trying for complexity though, with the superheros having internal disagreements and all.

    Seems like a major way that it seeks to de-pedestal Superman is by the classic method of “You are a leader. Something bad happened on your watch. You could theoretically have prevented it, you didn’t, therefore you are complicit in it and do not deserve your role or your reputation for having helped anyone ever.”

    This is the easiest way in the world to condemn any person or institution that has responsibility for others. We live in a fallen world where bad stuff happens regularly, so sooner or later something really, really bad will happen in our vicinity and we won’t see it coming. Then, boom! We’re outta there. Our detractors can claim that this kind of thing is characteristic of our system and that we are indifferent to it.

    Not that I’m bitter.

    Liked by 2 people

    1. Glad to hear you’re not bitter 😀

      And words are indeed the weapons of choice in this day and age. Which is way more dangerous than any old outlaw with a rifle or sixgun back in the day 😦


      1. I’ve heard of a few good ones but, the only one I’ve read that I didm’t hate was ‘Gotham by Gaslight’. However I’ve not read it in years and the only thing I remember is that I enjoyed it back then. Wonder what thoughts a re-read might unlock …

        Liked by 1 person

            1. Hahahahaha. It definitely helps that I AM a huge superman fan.

              If you’re a batman fan, and haven’t read it yet, then I do recommend I, Joker. I went through a bunch of Elseworld stories years ago and that was about the only Batman one that stuck out to me. I think I retroactively gave it 4 or 5 stars? I still remember the name anyway, so that has to count for something 😀

              Liked by 1 person

              1. Batman is literally my all-time favourite comic book hero. The Joker is one of my favourite villains (I have a guilty pleasure of loving Mr Freeze but rarely see comics with him featured). So I’ll certainly try and get my hands on I, Joker! Thanks for that suggestion 🙂

                Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s